tech.gadgets.video.geekculture.gaming.kittens.
Jason (my new boss, btw) went on a little rant yesterday about Facebook, the wall-garden effect, and the general overload of information coming from the social networking sites. This is something that I’ve been thinking about quite a bit lately: how do I manage all of these networks, and what benefit am I really getting out of them?
Since at this point I’m a member of too many networking sites to even begin listing (it’s a sick, sick addiction) I thought I’d talk a little bit about the few I use regularly, and what I use them for.
Facebook: I’ll talk about this one first, since it’s the one that’s giving Jason the most grief currently. I add everyone to Facebook as a friend (I’m not sure why I decided that was a good idea, but I did).
It’s true that it can make it a tad overwhelming, but at the same time I enjoy seeing what people post, and I like getting a peek into everyone’s lives. Is that weird? The invitations and group invites are something I largely ignore, but only out of necessity – if I joined them all, it would be completely unusable. As for the email notifications, I have all of my Facebook items bypassing my inbox (they go under the *misc tag), and filtered as such it makes it easier for me to check periodically.
Facebook is only as daunting as you let it be. There’s a lot of information floating around, but with the correct filtering it can be useful.
MySpace: I only use this to keep in touch with friends back East, or from college. Most of my friends haven’t left MySpace – they use it because it’s all they know, and they have no reason to try something different. I don’t even use the email address I’m registered with there anymore, so I don’t worry about notifications. Honestly, I’m bitter that I still have to use that bloated, inflexible website ever again.
Twitter: I’ve fallen off the Twitter bandwagon a little. I still enjoy using the site, but I’ve noticed lately that it’s the same people posting the same links to their blogs all the time. Somewhere along the line it became a tool for bloggers to pimp their own stuff, and the fun interactions have decreased. I still love Twitter, and the Twitter guys are great, but I may need to re-evaluate who I’m following to bring back the interesting bits.
Pownce: I’m still excited over this one – I love that I can post links, files and events all in one place. But the best part is that now I can create sets of people that I can post for and monitor. There’s a lot of information, just like every other site, but now I can whittle down and choose what I want to view.
So anyway, I guess what I’m tying to say is that you have to choose which sites are valuable to you, and then find a good way of handling the torrent of information that is sent your way. Gmail filters are a godsend for me, because they keep the social networking spam out of my inbox and stored away for perusal at my convenience.
I agree with Jason that people are getting too “splintered” with social networking sites, and that’s why I’ve decided to make sure a couple of them are always up-to-date (Flickr and Last.fm are mainstays for me). I think everyone is still in the trial and error period – the best sites always float to the top, and that’s where people will stay.
No related posts.
33 Responses for "Social networking overload"
I’m on Twitter, Pownce, and Last.fm only. (I seem to always forget about Flickr; I guess I don’t take enough pictures.) I’ve only recently gotten back into social networking of any kind after deleting my MySpace account, and I only use those three because they’re fun to use. I only follow a handful of people on each (and most of my friends aren’t even on these sites anyway, so they’re mostly people like tech media peeps and “online friends”), so for now they’re fun. I hope they never get out of control for me.
The only other type of thing like this I use is Livejournal, which I’ve used for over six years. That’s probably the only social-type thing I could consider my “home” site.
Maybe if you weren’t so popular!
I used Twitter, Last.fm, Del.icio.us, and Pownce. I’m not big on Pownce, it’s kind of cool but it seems to much like Jaiku to me. Maybe I have explored it enough.
Veronica, I have two questions for you though. Do you use an RSS Aggregator, and if so, which one? and are you planning to attend Blizzcon August 3-4th?
Tyler – I use Google Reader for RSS, and I’ll be attending BlizzCon on the 3rd!
created a comunity for you on orkut
http://www.orkut.com/Community.aspx?cmm=36764115&refresh=1
I’m one of the many who has WAY too many social networking accounts (Facebook, Flickr, Myspace, Message Boards, Twitter). However, I’ve found myself only using Livejournal and Facebook regularly. I use Facebook only because of the school connections. Livejournal is probably the best social networking site out there because of the level of control you get over the information you receive. More sites need to let users apply filters(Gmail does have an AWESOME filtering system) for the web to be effective.
Oh, and can’t forget Last.fm/Pandora
Pownce and facebook. That is all I need.
Agreed on the recent self-pimping trends on Twitter. I think that’s just bad manners. Scoble and Chris Pirillo immediately come to mind. Still, I like the simplicity and immediacy of Twitter interactions.
Answer “the question”, share a selfless link, reply to Twits, or welcome others to the Twitter-verse. Pretty much anything else reeks of spam. Bots don’t belong on Twitter either–I’m sure Ryan would disagree.
My Pownce account has laid fallow for weeks. I just haven’t had the time.
AS Merlin Mann would say, given your fame, you have a “first world problem”.
Hmm… I have a presence on a lot of “networks”: Pownce, Twitter, Blogger, Facebook, Tumblr, Jaiku. However I really only post to Pownce (if it is something longer than 140 or a link) and Twitter. I have Pownce feeding into Twitter. Twitter then feeds into both Tumblr and Facebook. My Blogger goes into Tumblr but not Facebook.
So, lots of networks, but only a few to update. Works for me.
May I recommend a free Mac-like social network interface? It’s called “My Opera.” I think it’s from the creators of the Opera browser. Their social networking site is very streamlined, clean, and most importantly… ad free! Once and awhile, I come a cross a bug on the site, but I report it to them and it’s soon fixed in time.
It operates just like MySpace, but it’s not as customizable, which is VERY important to keep the bloating to a minimum. Only if I can get all my friends off MySpace and onto Opera.
I’m working at a small movie studio in Connecticut and my producer has always largely had the job of knowing and staying in contact with everyone who could ever potentially be useful to a project, but now with all the social networking sites, it’s getting really insane. Essentially, the studio has to maintain an active presence on every major social networking site and keep on top of what everyone is doing, which is made difficult by all the useful information often being buried by notifications that the guy who wore the monkey suit 6 years ago’s cat is being really cute right now. We have to keep up the illusion of maintaining a personal and individual relationship via the latest means with all of the people we might need. For my producer, a large part of his job is cultivating these relationships, so he gets involved under his own name and not that of the company.
My guess is that your problem is similar – your job is one where you are a visible public figure and thus social networking is mixing your work and your personal social life and sort of overwhelming the network. There is no ability on a network like facebook to distinguish (even privately) between your real friends and your work contacts. My guess is that this sort of functionality will have to be built into the utilities as more and more people use social networking professionally and not just to look at pictures of their friends!
Calacanis (your new boss) has problems with the use of you and yours… weird.
hey veronica.. I’m an Iranian girl, long time I’ve been readin your blog.. I’m used to it!
just wanted to inform you
And about Twitter, yeah it’s not as fun as it was!
I just recently dumped them ALL. Folks can come to my blog to see what is going on with me. Most of those sites are a joke anyway, and others are created just to make us feel MORE important then we actually are.
I can’t believe that Veronica is not registered with 8apps. com
I have to agree that Twitter is not as fun anymore but Pownce is really good. They only need API so people can develop desktops apps that don’t suck ( read: Adobe AIR). I have an account on Myspace but I never use it and it’s blank. Facebook was a carbon copy of Myspace in the beginning, but they’d improved alot since. Yes, I use Facebook now more often. 8apps is a hybrid that includes social networking, task management and “Blueprint” where people can co-work on the projects. Altahough I haven’t seen anyone that uses that feature. Usually people use Handshake social networking. Jaiku hmm, what to say about it except: ” I don’t like it -period!” I am really curious about which social networking service is gonna get out of the business first?
Amazing. I am going through the same mental/online evaluation as you are right now V. Of course, I’m not, nor am I trying to be, as popular as you. But, I would love to hit a certain quality level of self-promotion throughout the intertubes, especially since I am now gaining some momentum in my writing career. I would absolutely love to see ONE solid virtual office/website that incorporated all these apps into its operation. I am going to keep MySpace for staying in touch with the online friends I have and make there. Every place else is up to being nixed in place of something better. Damn glad to have you to watch to see how to get through all this crap. Thanks V!
Veronica, I’ll be at Blizzcon too for Epileptic Gaming. We should have lunch or something
Too many social network memberships would give me “whimsy overload” and I’m too pragmatic for that…
Memberships: Flickr, Friendster (both seldom active). If forums count: CNET (very active) and Make: (seldom active)
I totally buy into the “Minimalism is the new little black dress.” If done well, you may only need a couple of memberships/websites that you really get a LOT out of. Of course, this idea may only work if working only work if you’re of certain social activity level, etc.
If I want to get in touch with friends online – I just spend time with e-mail and use the “Reply To:”, “Reply To All:”, etc. appropriately.
I love the CNET community and am glad that I was eased into being active via the great podcast that were/are very appreciative of the lister/user-community. As a result, I strongly believe in open-/crowd-sourcing and the user-community effect (especially if the community is extraordinarily diverse in its knowledge base).
Specific example: I was about to post a question on fixing my ‘94 Jeep (gas guzzler I’ll be donating it at the end of the year) and was about to post it on a Jeep community website. Since I’ve been active on CNET I’ve had a strong belief that I really would like to join something and be very active on it. Since I didn’t have a strong desire to be active in yet another user community – I posted the question in an appropriate CNET forum and got a great response. With this, I was again amazed at the community’s vast knowledge base and found it unnecessary to join specialty site until I’ve outgrown CNET.
Best,
Shalin
?….You can go to account settings on myspace and change it so you don’t get a single notification. Maybe this is years to late for you Veronica. Hehe
Veronica,
I’m curious, what are some of the feeds that you get from Google Reader?
-Hami
I gave up on Myspace a long time ago. I never got into facebook, because I’m an ugly person — not being down on myself, some people just aren’t made to be in front of a camera.
I just got started with Twitter and already I’m kinda getting tired of it…seems more like advertisements for blogs to me. I’m trying so hard to embrace this “social networking” movement on the net and failing miserably. I tried last.fm, still have an account there, but just don’t use it that much.
However, WoW could be the reason I don’t like social networking sites…I have all my social interaction I need on WoW. I’ve even stopped frequenting the ubuntu and socialdiscussion.com forums too. I can’t even keep a decent blog going to save my life.
Yes, I’m a geek and failing at it!
Hi Veronica. There is definitely an overload of social networking sites these days, and only a few will stand the test of time. I’m actually surprised that you still have to use MySpace (i’m glad i never succumbed) because your friends back east haven’t moved over to Facebook yet.
I’m from NY and go to school in boston and just about everyone I know is on facebook. I’m assuming you’re only a few years older than me (i’m 22), so we’re basically in the same demographic. Even if they haven’t signed up yet, I’m sure your friends have heard of facebook. It’s definitely the only place I know where I can catch up with people I haven’t seen in years just by remembering their name.
Also, If I were a known personality such as yourself, I probably wouldn’t have accepted everyone that adds you as a friend on facebook. Given facebook’s popularity, i’m sure it’s horribly overwhelming and creates a negative experience. This is why it bothers me when known journalists somewhat “hate” on facebook because they don’t see the advantage of belonging to a site where all your friends are. (Btw, i’m not saying that’s what you’re doing). I was happy to see that Leo Laporte didn’t accept strangers on facebook.
Good luck at your new job. I’m sure you’ll be producing great content pretty soon.
i’m still on friendster and myspace but purely just as a way to keep in touch with people. rather than always update emails and contact info, those social sites enable me to get in contact with them should the need arise. other than using them as address books i have no other use for them. flickr is by far my fav, tho its focus is primarily on photos which is why i make it my number one site. i have no desire to join any of the new networks, nor do i see a need to… but to each his own… or her own in this case.
Wow. Way to nail down the social networking thing V. I have yet to try pownce (though I am thinking about it) and am doing ok with Facebook. Myspace is definitely something I can live without.
It hasnt become unmanageable as I do not know tons of people, but it seems to be growing nicely and can stay in its pot just a bit longer
Approximate quote of Dave Winer at WordCamp: “My world and the world of Myspace users never intersect.”
Which, in a idealized world, might work well for all.
But as you say: “I only use this to keep in touch with friends back East, or from college.”
That is so right-on about my use of Myspace too. After using it with initial enthusiasm and then tiring of it, I finally decided a month ago to “future-proof” my page by setting up an away message and putting in four different widgets so my college friends who still use the site can see what’s new.
I think that the network effect keeping people on Myspace is still very strong in other parts of the country, certainly a lot of my old friends are still on it.
I couldn’t agree with you more. I listen to too many podcasts, and latey, I’ve become overwhelmed with trying to keep up with what is hot and what’s not. To make matters worse, at least for me, most of my friends are not interested in following me. So I go to all the touble of signing up, only to be the only one there. Even the IT staff look at me funny when I bring up the subject of joining these sites. AHHHHH.
Veronica, why do you use Google Reader? The portability of it?
I kind of like having new news pop up in the corner of my screen and tell me when it happens. Know any good feed readers that can do that?
Here’s a social network that is great example of how to use edgecraft(Seth Godin) to make a remarkable product: http://iminlikewithyou.com. Now you can bid on people like they were a piece of meat with out going to the bar! It’s really fun and has kept my interest long after joining. There are some real freaks on there too, just to keep it spunky. Plus, it is going to be interesting to see if Wallop(all Flash) will disintegrate after the all new Flash version of iilwy.com is released. So pull the trigger on your lame SN and go where the action is. [legal notice: no, I don't work for them
]
[...] Networking – Web 2.0 che stanno diventando sempre di pi? una droga. Mi piace quello che ha scritto Veronica Belmont che , oltre ad essere decisamente un’esperta in materia … ? (diciamocelo) anche una [...]
@Brian2.0 – I’m already on there! http://www.iminlikewithyou.com/profile/detail/Veronica
@Veronica – Good one! http://media.iminlikewithyou.com/2030/photos/20309eqdvp257ey0j6_mediumver.jpg, I wear my stunna shades B) at night! Now, that’s what I call keepin’ it real with the Bay Area flava. It’s sad
when people from the tech industry don’t get Hyphy(http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hyphy) and that’s why Sergey Brin and Larry Page need to keep it real and Gost Ride the whip(http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ghost_ride_the_whip)!
I have an idea… maybe we should make a social network for the Bay Area, and call it http://stunnashades.com, where you have to wear stunna shades in your profile picture.
oops, gotta take that comma off, guess the auto-link parse doesn’t knock off the comma(okay… who wrote the regex for this?) So here it is again: http://media.iminlikewithyou.com/2030/photos/20309eqdvp257ey0j6_mediumver.jpg
Leave a reply